19-10-2022 · Insight

How climate change impacts different asset classes

We believe the climate impact on asset returns is not yet priced-in, and that it will become more significant over time.

    Authors

  • Peter van der Welle - Strategist Sustainable Multi Asset Solutions

    Peter van der Welle

    Strategist Sustainable Multi Asset Solutions

  • Laurens Swinkels - Head of Quant Strategy

    Laurens Swinkels

    Head of Quant Strategy

In our recent Expected Returns, ‘The Age of Confusion’, we included the impact of climate change in our estimated returns for each asset class for the second consecutive year. Our methodology is still developing but we are clear that climate change will have a growing impact on investment returns in the years and decades to come, and in this insight we share what we have learned so far about modeling this impact.

The first instinct of investors when considering a hugely significant global challenge like climate change has been an understandable one – to exclude obvious climate change contributors during portfolio construction. In a recent survey, 27% of global investors have made public pledges for net-zero portfolios in or before 2050. As part of this, institutional investors plan to divest 19% of their portfolios because they are too carbon intensive, mostly in the asset classes equities and corporate bonds. This may lead to negative price pressure on assets with a high carbon footprint, leading to lower returns on the medium term.

Consider both physical and transition risks

We believe it’s potentially illuminating to consider the impact on expected returns of the physical risks (like floods or droughts) and the impacts of transition risks (like changing investment patterns, regulations or taxes designed to mitigate against climate change) on all asset classes. In this way we will get a holistic picture of how investors can take climate change into account for portfolio construction and investment decision-making purposes. Using this framework and taking into account other variables where appropriate like the discount rate, economic growth, and the carbon price, we assessed how climate change is likely to impact different asset classes from 2023-2027.

Government debt

We started by noting not every government is equally vulnerable to climate change and the energy transition, so we have developed a Country Sustainability Ranking 1 which contains a climate and energy sub-score. This is based on indicators such as country carbon efficiency, the share of renewable energy, and climate risk indicators, and is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1 | Robeco's country climate and energy score

Figure 1 | Robeco's country climate and energy score

Source: Robeco. Scores range from 1 (worst) to 10 (best). Scores as of April 2022.

Developed market government bonds

We assessed the climate change impact on developed market government bonds as neutral over the next five years. This is because government bond returns tend to be positively related to real economic growth, and negatively related to higher inflation. In the next five years the climate impact alone is likely to reduce growth below the previous trend level.

Penn2 (2022) surveys 55 academic studies on the effect of climate change and reports that the estimates vary considerably depending on the methodology used and geography examined. He finds an annual 0.3% lower global GDP a realistic synthesis versus a business-as-usual scenario. For inflation we believe the trend towards renewable energy is having an inflationary impact, an example of a transition cost. These two climate impacts, a lower GDP growth trajectory, and higher inflation due to transition costs, will cancel each other out from an expected returns perspective.

Emerging markets government debt

While the same dynamics apply as in the developed market assessment, there is a negative climate signal for investments in emerging market debt over the next five years. We can identify at least two reasons why credit spreads of countries that are more vulnerable to climate change may be wider than comparable countries with less climate risk.

First, the physical risks are likely to be larger, leading to higher government expenses to repair damage resulting from climate-related disasters such as floods and storms. Second, energy in emerging markets is more likely generated cheaply but with low carbon efficiency, for example through coal-fired plants.

Large investments to change to more carbon-efficient technologies are required, and typically the government has to pick up part of the bill. In emerging markets this combination of physical risks and transition risks will lead to higher yields, and therefore be negative for bond returns in our assessment.

Corporate credit

For the corporate bond market we have access to data on climate risk in Figure 2. We found that carbon-emitting corporates are more prevalent in high yield indices than in investment grade. This may be due to climate change risk already materializing and carbon-intense companies becoming less creditworthy for long-run debt. However, it can also be due to the heavily fluctuating energy prices over the past couple of years, which materially affect the expected cash flows from operations from carbon-intense companies. All in all, investment grade receives a neutral climate signal, and high yield a negative climate signal.

Figure 2 | Climate change risk metrics for corporate bonds

Figure 2 | Climate change risk metrics for corporate bonds

Source: Robeco

Equities

We believe equity investors should consider how climate change will impact the cashflow generation abilities and the discount rate of the typical company in an assessment of net present value. Losses can be due to physical risk, for example when droughts or floods damage the production facilities, due to stranded assets related to new energy sources, or an increased price to emit carbon. Companies innovating for the energy transition may also benefit from climate change risk. In the next five years we expect more equity investors to start to scrutinize the risks that could result from climate change, leading to a larger discount rate on certain equity markets.

Emerging market equities more impacted

Applying the same method we used for corporate bonds, we assessed the climate risks of different sectors, both in developed market and emerging equities, in Figure 3. We evaluated carbon footprint, Climate Value at Risk, implied temperature rise, and this time also climate beta. This is a proprietary Robeco measure that indicates how sensitive the return of a stock is to the excess return of a polluting-minus-clean factor. Based on these variables we expect a negative but limited impact on overall expected developed market equity returns from the repricing of climate risk over the next five years.

These measures indicate emerging market equities are more vulnerable than developed market equities when it comes to climate change risk, mainly because of a much higher carbon footprint and projected temperature rises, so we give a negative climate signal.

Figure 3 | Climate change risk metrics for equities

Figure 3 | Climate change risk metrics for equities

Source: Robeco

Commodities

Climate change seems to be a double-edged sword when it comes to commodities. On the one hand, demand for commodities might decrease as global economic activity slows. On the other hand, increased physical risk resulting from climate change could see more frequent negative supply shocks hitting commodities, especially agricultural commodities. In the scenario of progress towards the Paris climate targets and the green energy transition, the commodity intensity of economic activity could increase due to increased demand for certain commodities like metals needed for electrification.

On balance, we give a positive climate signal to commodity markets, as we expect climate change will put upward pressure on commodity prices.

Conclusion

We have presented data modeling the climate change impact on asset class returns and, so far, for the largest asset classes like DM government bonds, that impact is limited. Nevertheless, it is clear that small changes in some variables like the carbon price could have an outsize effect on returns in the future. We expect more measurable climate impact each time we do our 5-year Expected Returns, and as the quality of data and our methodology improves.

Figure 4 | Climate signal for each asset class

Figure 4 | Climate signal for each asset class

Source: Robeco

Footnotes

1 Carbon Beta: A Market-Based Measure of Climate Risk by Joop Huij, Dries Laurs, Philip A. Stork, Remco C. J. Zwinkels: SSRN
2 Penn, M., 2022, “Assessing climate impacts on growth”, Absolute Strategy Research.

Let's keep the conversation going

Keep track of fast-moving events in sustainable and quantitative investing, trends and credits with our newsletters.

Don’t miss out
Robeco

Robeco aims to enable its clients to achieve their financial and sustainability goals by providing superior investment returns and solutions.

Important information This disclaimer applies to any documents and the verbal or written comments of any person in presentations or webinars on this website and taken together is referred to herein as the “Information”. The services to which the Information relate are NOT FOR RETAIL CLIENTS - The information contained in the Website is solely intended for professional investors, defined as investors which (1) qualify as professional clients within the meaning of the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID), (2) have requested to be treated as professional clients within the meaning of the MiFID or (3) are authorized to receive such information under any other applicable laws and must not be relied or acted upon by any other persons. This Information does not constitute an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any financial product, and may not be relied upon in connection with the purchase or sale of any financial product. You are cautioned against using this Information as the basis for making a decision to purchase any financial product. To the extent that you rely on the Information in connection with any investment decision, you do so at your own risk. The Information does not purport to be complete on any topic addressed. The Information may contain data or analysis prepared by third parties and no representation or warranty about the accuracy of such data or analysis is provided.
In all cases where historical performance is presented, please note that past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results and should not be relied upon as the basis for making an investment decision. Investors may not get back the amount originally invested. Neither Robeco Institutional Asset Management B.V. nor any of its affiliates guarantees the performance or the future returns of any investments. If the currency in which the past performance is displayed differs from the currency of the country in which you reside, then you should be aware that due to exchange rate fluctuations the performance shown may increase or decrease if converted into your local currency. Robeco Institutional Asset Management B.V. (“Robeco”) expressly prohibits any redistribution of the Information without the prior written consent of Robeco. The Information is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person or entity in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or use is contrary to law, rule or regulation. Certain information contained in the Information includes calculations or figures that have been prepared internally and have not been audited or verified by a third party. Use of different methods for preparing, calculating or presenting information may lead to different results. Robeco Institutional Asset Management UK Limited (“RIAM UK”) is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. RIAM UK, 30 Fenchurch Street, Part Level 8, London EC3M 3BD (FCA Reference No:1007814). The company is registered in England and Wales under Ref No. 15362605.

In all cases where historical performance is presented, please note that past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results and should not be relied upon as the basis for making an investment decision. Investors may not get back the amount originally invested. Neither Robeco Institutional Asset Management B.V. nor any of its affiliates guarantees the performance or the future returns of any investments. If the currency in which the past performance is displayed differs from the currency of the country in which you reside, then you should be aware that due to exchange rate fluctuations the performance shown may increase or decrease if converted into your local currency. Robeco Institutional Asset Management B.V. (“Robeco”) expressly prohibits any redistribution of the Information without the prior written consent of Robeco. The Information is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person or entity in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or use is contrary to law, rule or regulation. Certain information contained in the Information includes calculations or figures that have been prepared internally and have not been audited or verified by a third party. Use of different methods for preparing, calculating or presenting information may lead to different results. Robeco Institutional Asset Management B.V. is authorised as a manager of UCITS and AIFs by the Netherlands Authority for the Financial Markets and subject to limited regulation in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority. Details about the extent of our regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority are available from us on request.